Cacio e Pepe

71 Comments

Cacio e Pepe is an Italian pasta dish that translates to cheese and pepper. It’s a long-time standard of Roman cuisine.

Recently my daughter asked if I’d ever made it, and I never have. As much as I love and respect the simplicity of authentic Italian dishes, this one probably never intrigued me enough because of the lack of “goodies” in it, like a little Prosciutto, or smoked salmon.

But I decided it was about time to make Cacio e Pepe and embrace the perfection that is a traditional pasta dish.

When I started researching the recipe online, it was like opening up an Italian Pandora’s box. There were so many criticisms of recipes, techniques, and so forth. I’ve always found that the Italians are the most passionate about their traditional recipes remaining traditional.

I personally don’t mind variations on the original, but nonetheless I closed the box and decided on the recipe I would use. The important goal of making Cacio e Pepe is a creaminess that is created without using butter or cream.
_MG_0291
Here’s what I did.

First I grated 8 ounces of Pecorino Romano cheese and set aside.

Then I place a large pot full of salted water on the stove over high heat. I chose basic spaghetti, 16 ounces, for my pasta.
_MG_0269

When the water boiled, I added the pasta and timed 9-10 minutes.
_MG_0273
_MG_0275
After the pasta was cooked, I poured some of the pasta water in a bowl, drained the pasta, and returned the pasta to the pot. I had a stirring spoon on hand, and immediate added some of the pasta water to the pot, stirring gently.

I then added about 2 teaspoons of coarsely ground pepper and the grated cheese, along with more pasta water as needed. Vigorous stirring was necessary to create a creaminess and incorporate the cheese.


Serve immediately, preferably in warmed pasta bowls.
_MG_0311
I added more coarsely-ground pepper.
_MG_0305

This dish is so much about the pepper!

I can now understand why this simple pasta dish has endured for centuries. I’ve always loved and respected the simplicity of many Italian dishes, but I think this one takes the cake.
_MG_0300

However, as wonderfu as Cacio e Pepe is, tomorrow I’m adding some Prosciutto or smoked salmon.

71 thoughts on “Cacio e Pepe

    • Oooohhhh, what a great idea! Which brings up something I’ve always wondered about – searing steaks coated in pepper. Doesn’t the pepper burn in the high heat? I always add pepper after the searing process. you?

      Like

  1. I only have a couple of pasta dishes I like to make. One has asparagus and chicken in it with a cream sauce. (It’s on our blog.) But your recipe for Cacio e Pepe looks delicious. I think I’d like a small dish of it with a salad and some grilled chicken. Thank you so much for this wonderful recipe.
    RuthAnn Ridley
    inspiringcuisine.com

    Liked by 1 person

    • I think it depends on your tastes. I love spicy food, and lots of flavor. This pasta is definitely subtle, although tasty. I had to make it the traditional way, and it was delicious. But then I added a few things…. My Italian ancestors are probably rolling in their graves!

      Like

  2. Remarkably delicious, isn’t it? It took me years before I first made it (or ordered it in a restaurant), because I thought it would be too simple. It isn’t, and it is now one of our favorites. When I make a variation, it is with sautéed or roasted vegetables. Not authentic, but good and more healthy.
    PS it goes without saying that with a dish like this, the quality of the pasta, cheese and black pepper all make a huge difference!
    PS2: from an etymological standpoint, I think it is cool that cheese, usually called formaggio in Italian, is called cacio here (cacio is closer to the germanic cheese/kaas/käse).

    Like

  3. I’ve never heard of this Mimi. Although I must have picked something up from it, as i put loads of black pepper on any food that is yellow. Can’t say I’m pastas biggest fan, but even this I’d have trouble not devouring.

    Like

    • Very interesting. And I have to remember to use black pepper! White pepper I’m a huge fan of. I’m not a carb addict, or I’d weigh even more than I do – but in its simplicity, this is a fabulous dish. And the pepper is wonderful in it!

      Like

    • Yeah, I know what you mean, although elevate almost sounds forced or faked, even though I know that’s not what you mean. As much as I love many many cuisines from around the world, I do think that the Italians are best at the simplest recipes yet made with only high quality and in season ingredients. I couldn’t be happy with this dish every day, but it is superb!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I honestly think the simplicity of the dish is what totally appeals to me. I can just taste it in my imagination. I appreciate how you’ve described achieving the creaminess. I can’t wait to make this. I have some fresh pepper that I look forward to adding. :-)

    Like

    • I made sure I got the right cheese, and there is a vigorous amount of stirring involved, but it was pretty amazing that there was no cream or butter in the pasta!!! Just simply good and peppery!

      Like

    • I honestly don’t know if that’s allowed!!! In fact, honestly, the stirring might be too rough for fresh pasta, unless it’s pretty sturdy. But nonetheless it is a fabulous recipe!

      Like

  5. I definitely agree with you Mimi that we sometimes feel that we need to add something to a dish when sometimes simplest is the tastiest, (and the easiest when we have run low on ingredients!) It looks great ! :)

    Like

  6. yeah! I never gave this dish much thought and then one day I decided to try it. It’s all in the freshly cracked pepper like you said, and the cheese quality. But somehow I remember the pepper contribution more than the cheese’s which seems weird. In any case… I’ve never been a big fan of mac&cheese but ‘m definitely a big fan cacio e pepe.

    Like

    • I’m not a Mac and cheese fan either. But then over 30 years ago I made my first pasta from an Italian cookbook that was pasta, Parmesan, butter and cream. Then I was hooked on real pasta dishes. You are right, tho, the pepper is the main flavor; the cheese just melts into a coating for the pasta. It’s fabulous, and I’m not a huge black pepper fan! I have to remind myself to use it. I grab for white pepper a lot!

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Not to long ago my granddaughters and I decided to make fresh pasta! It was a great idea! We made bow ties and eventually just strings because we got tired. I didn’t want a heavy sauce so I found a recipe Aglio e Olio! It’s basically a sauce with olive oil and garlic. The garlic is sliced and cooked in the olive oil until it’s sizzling. Then you add the cooked pasta and some of the pasta water thereby making a sauce! Best thing we’ve ever eaten!! I added a little basil because I love basil but it was superb!

    Like

  8. This is such a great dish, Mimi, and your recipe’s a good one. It’s my “go-to” supper when I just don’t feel like cooking and it sure beats anything that a delivery boy will bring me. :)

    Like

Please... write something!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s